← Back to Blog

Understanding PICK Chart: definitions, examples, and usage in project management

5
minute read
Try Bonsai - Best Project Management Software
Try Bonsai - Best Project Management Software
Try it free
Updated on:
June 3, 2024
June 3, 2024
Table of contents
Try Bonsai - Best Project Management Software
Discover Bonsai all-in-one business management software.

A PICK Chart is a tool of Lean Six Sigma under process improvement concepts for effectual project management. It supports the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase by placing action items in a visual comparison, known as the Impact Effort Matrix, by their impact and ease of implementation.

The quadrants of the PICK Chart are Plan, Implement, Challenge, and Kill, and through this, it is possible to view the potential return on investment of a project. The PICK Chart, thus, forms an integral part with Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma methodologies to assure comprehensive and guided decision-making.

Introduction to PICK Chart

Source

A PICK Chart or Impact-Effort Matrix is a very useful Lean Six Sigma tool that is regularly used in both Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma to enable the sorting of process improvement ideas as part of Phase 2: Identify and Prioritize Opportunities. Standing for Possible, Implement, Challenge, and Kill, this title simply represents ranges on the matrix. As a chart, it gives a visual comparison of potential return on investment versus ease/cost of implementation, hence helping with the efficient strategizing of action items.

In a PICK Chart, improvement ideas are plotted according to the impact and effort applied, availing a simple but very effective way to prioritize and manage such projects according to their feasibility and potential impact. The matrix speeds up not only the selection process but also assists in aligning business needs with betterment initiatives.

What is a PICK Chart?

A PICK Chart is a simple tool usable in Lean Six Sigma, among other process improvement methodologies, to categorize process improvement ideas and isolate priority action items. The name PICK actually stands for Possible, Implement, Challenge, and Kill, which represent the different category options that the tool offers.

This chart also represents an Impact Effort Matrix, or Ease Impact Matrix, which contrasts the ideas and their potential impact with the ease or cost of implementation. This visual comparison would assist greatly in the phase of identifying and prioritizing opportunities and thereby maximizing return on investment in lean manufacturing.

The origin of PICK Chart

A PICK chart is a graphical tool in organizing ideas, developed as part of Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma methodologies. The methodologies reduce the complication in the manufacturing process of the product and also reduce wastage by improving the return on investment. The PICK chart helps in categorizing and placing the ideas of improvement in order of importance, making them easy to implement.

This tool uses an Impact Effort Matrix that visually compares possible actions and is thus very vital in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities phase. This makes closeness with which action items are classified—that is, easy to conduct—on process improvement projects, according to the expected impact and ease or cost of implementing the actions.

Components of a PICK Chart

A PICK chart is a Lean Six Sigma tool used in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase for process improvement ideas. It stands for Possible, Implement, Challenge, and Kill, which categorize action items based on impact and ease/cost of implementation. The chart consists of two axes, namely the Impact Effort Matrix or vertical axis representing possible return on investment and the Ease Impact Matrix or horizontal axis representing ease of implementation. This comparative, multi-dimensional visual tool facilitates arranging improvement ideas. It helps in making decisions on the implementation status by team members dealing in Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma projects. It ensures that all resources are used for developing with maximum benefit and least efforts.

Understanding the four quadrants

Definition: The Four Quadrants is a basic Lean Six Sigma tool that is used by process improvement techniques like Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma. It is made up of the following two tools:

  • Impact Effort Matrix
  • Ease Impact Matrix

Both of these are used to categorize and set priority items to take action on the basis of ease or cost of implementation as well as their potential return on investment. During the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase of every process improvement work, a visual comparison is what is availed by both sets of matrix. By examining the ideas against these two parameters, organizations can be able to deploy or introduce the most appropriate changes achievable. The Four Quadrants tool is thus imperative for maximal efficiency as well as profit-making.

How to plot tasks on a PICK Chart

A PICK chart is a Lean Six Sigma tool used to categorize tasks or improvement ideas in the 'Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase. It is possible to figure the return on investment for each action item by an Impact Effort Matrix, sometimes also referred to as an Ease Impact Matrix. The size of the step on the x-axis is the ease/cost of implementation, and on the y-axis is the impact of the task on process improvement ideas. You would simply start by identifying all the possible action items. Then, place each of the action items in the matrix based on the impact and ease of implementation. Quick visual comparisons help differentiate 'quick wins' from 'longer-term projects' and thus prioritizes tasks, making lean manufacturing and Six Sigma process improvements stronger.

Benefits of using a PICK Chart in project management

Source

A PICK chart, belonging to Lean Six Sigma tools in the tool suite, is an effective way to categorize and prioritize process improvement ideas during the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities phase of project management. It becomes an easy way to compare potential action items through an impact effort matrix—which shows ease or cost of implementation against expected return on investment. By using PICK charts in project management, Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma projects, one is able to streamline decision-making, engender transparency in the workspace, and so efforts are in line with business needs. Therefore, it simplifies the implementation of improvements and optimizes the allocation of resources for maximum benefits.

Benefits of using a Bonsai in project management

The benefits of using Bonsai in project management are extensive and impactful for businesses seeking to optimize their operations. Bonsai's comprehensive suite of project management tools not only simplifies administrative tasks but also empowers teams to deliver successful projects with greater efficiency and control.

Enhanced decision-making process

Implementing a Lean Six Sigma tool within a company structure enhances the decision-making process. It uses methodologies like the impact effort matrix, which aids in categorizing process improvement ideas based on their impact and effort, thus giving a visual comparison. One can thus come up with effective action items through the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities phase. Such tools champion Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma principles, which simplify the process of implementation and in turn gives a return on investment. Ideas for improvement can thus be developed with a focus on ease/cost of implementation. Decision-Making: thus, a simplified but productive approach can be done towards decision making.

Improved project prioritization

The Lean Six Sigma tool, Impact Effort Matrix will improve project prioritization. The categorization and visualization of process improvement ideas based on return on investment and ease/cost of implementation. The implementation of these strategies can aid the emphasis of the action items needed in this Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase based on the return on investment of each idea and the ease/cost of implementation of each idea as well. Also, Ease Impact Matrix, which will ensure a simplified yet visual comparison of project potentials based on the ease of implementation and the projected impact. Both principles of Six Sigma and Lean Manufacturing will ensure that the prioritization process is simplified and improved, leaving more room for efficient resource use.

Increased team collaboration

Implementation of Lean Six Sigma tools such as Impact Effort Matrix aids the process of identifying and prioritizing opportunities phase, which triggers deep ideas of improvements. This would help in increasing collaboration between team members, as the action items are well defined, categorized, and visual comparison done based on the return on investment of each idea and ease/cost implementation of each idea. This approach of Lean Manufacturing would help in the driving of strategic discussion, which will, in turn, enable the team members to support their roles and responsibility in light of broader organizational goals. This, in turn increases the ability of driving teamwork that supports the ease of implementation and drives return on investment.

Step-by-step guide to creating a PICK Chart

Source

To create a PICK chart, which is a Lean Six Sigma tool used in Lean Manufacturing, the first step is to categorize and list your process improvement ideas based on their ease/cost of implementation and their potential return on investment using an Impact Effort Matrix. This matrix maps out the ideas based on their impact (vertical axis) and effort (horizontal axis).

The second step is to transfer these ideas onto the PICK (Possible, Implement, Challenge and Kill) chart for a visual comparison. This helps in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase of Six Sigma, assisting in the selection of high impact, low effort action items for implementation.

The PICK chart defines the quadrant in which each idea lies, allowing for easier analysis of its feasibility. It's a straightforward tool that helps clarify the ease of implementation and expected results of improvement ideas.

Identifying and listing down ideas

Implementing Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma techniques are essential for successful process improvement. The Lean Six Sigma tool is particularly effective in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase. Using tools like the Impact Effort Matrix and Ease Impact Matrix allows for easy visualization and categorizing of potential improvement ideas based on their return on investment and ease/cost of implementation.

Listing down action items after visual comparison not only streamlines the process but also enables easy implementation. Highlighting these points, we can then discern the potential impact against the ease of implementation. These guidelines foster an environment that encourages growth and efficiency without overwhelming the system.

Ranking each idea based on impact and effort

Implementing Lean Six Sigma tools is crucial for categorizing and prioritizing process improvement ideas. The Impact Effort Matrix and Ease Impact Matrix offer a visual comparison of each action item based on effort and impact, aiding in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase of project planning.

Factors considered typically include ease of implementation and potential return on investment. Ranking each idea in this manner helps to forecast the ease/cost of implementation against potential benefits. In correlation to Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma principles, this can streamline decision making, boost efficiency, and maximize productivity.

Plotting the Ideas on the PICK Chart

In Lean Manufacturing and the Six Sigma methodology, the PICK chart is a tool employed in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase. This Lean Six Sigma tool helps categorize process improvement ideas based on their ease of implementation and anticipated return on investment. It provides a visual comparison on the Impact Effort Matrix, including the Ease Impact Matrix.

The PICK chart can be used to sort out and prioritize action items, making it an effective tool for implementation. It allows for an objective evaluation of improvement ideas, crucial for maintaining the lean principle of eliminating waste and promoting efficiency.

Examples of PICK chart in real-world scenarios

In Lean Six Sigma, the PICK chart - also known as 'Impact Effort Matrix' is often used at the 'Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase'. It is a visual comparison tool that helps categorize process improvement ideas according to their ease/cost of implementation and potential impact on business goals. This aids in decision making and helps teams to focus their efforts efficiently.

For example, in a Lean Manufacturing context, teams might use a PICK chart to evaluate improvement ideas, ranging from reducing production errors to implementing a new software system. Each idea is plotted based on perceived ease of implementation and estimated return on investment, allowing for a comparison of action items and determining which to implement first.

Using PICK Chart in marketing campaigns

Using the PICK Chart, a Lean Six Sigma tool, in marketing campaigns can significantly ease the implementation process and categorize ideas based on their impact and effort. During the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase, strategic action items are reviewed and the return on investment from different tactics is visually compared.

Commonly used in Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma, the Impact Effort Matrix facilitates the filtration of improvement ideas, organizing them regarding ease/cost of implementation contrasted with potential benefits. Thus, marketers can use the PICK chart to streamline their process improvement ideas and optimize their campaigns.

Applying PICK Chart in product development

In product development, the PICK chart, an integral component of Lean Six Sigma tool kit, is primarily used to categorize and prioritize process improvement ideas. It's a visual comparison tool, also known as the Impact Effort Matrix, for easing the implementation of Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma principles. It helps to identify and prioritize opportunities in the 'Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase'.

The PICK chart enables teams to arrange their improvement ideas and action items based on the ease/cost of implementation and expected return on investment. This aids in formulating an Ease Impact Matrix for each idea, leading to efficient resource allocation.

Software tools for creating PICK Charts

Tools such as Lean Six Sigma are pivotal in creating PICK charts as part of the Implement phase in both Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma. These charts serve as a visual comparison aid for categorizing the ease/cost of implementation of various process improvement ideas, based on the estimated return on investment (ROI).

The Impact Effort Matrix and Ease Impact Matrix are useful tools in the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase. They allow teams to evaluate and prioritize action items based on their ease of implementation and potential impact. Improvement ideas can thus be evaluated and planned effectively using these tools.

Microsoft Excel and PowerPoint

Implementing Six Sigma and Lean Manufacturing concepts in a business environment often involves using tools like Microsoft Excel and PowerPoint. These platforms facilitate the ease of implementation for process improvement ideas, helping to categorize and prioritize action items. Using Excel's data-handling capabilities allows for more in-depth visual comparison for the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase.

Additionally, PowerPoint aids in presenting the Impact Effort Matrix and the Ease Impact Matrix, important Lean Six Sigma tools. These matrices help in calculating the return on investment of the proposed changes, thus assisting with decision-making in business operations.

Overall, Microsoft Excel and PowerPoint prove to be effective in driving continuous process improvement and achieving a substantial return on investment due to their data analysis and visual display functionalities respectively.

Lucidchart

Lucidchart is a vital Lean Six Sigma tool that helps categorize and implement process improvement ideas. It is particularly useful during the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase, as it allows for visual comparison and easy tracking of action items.

Within this context, its benefits extend to Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma approaches by enabling the creation of an Impact Effort Matrix and an Ease Impact Matrix. These matrices aid in measuring the return on investment and the ease/cost of implementation of improvement ideas, thereby optimizing resource allocation and enhancing overall productivity.

Above all, Lucidchart enables ease of implementation, providing a platform that effectively translates process improvement ideas into actionable and tangible plans.

SmartDraw

SmartDraw is a valuable Lean Six Sigma tool that effortlessly aids in Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma implementations. It offers a visual comparison approach to categorize and prioritize process improvement ideas, providing an easy-to-use platform to create Impact Effort Matrix and Ease Impact Matrix.

This tool not only shortens the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase, but also ensures appropriate action items are promptly set. Besides, SmartDraw provides an intuitive framework to evaluate the ease/cost of implementation, ensuring a significant return on investment through the ease of implementation of selected improvement ideas.

Common mistakes when using PICK Charts and how to avoid them

Source

When employing PICK charts, a Lean Six Sigma tool in Lean Manufacturing, it’s essential to avoid common mistakes. These blunders include failing to categorize ideas correctly, overlooking the full return on investment, and neglecting to identify the true ease/cost of implementation. To sidestep these pitfalls, let’s delve into some strategies:

1. Define clear parameters

During the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase, take a moment to clearly define the parameters for each category in the Impact Effort Matrix. This ensures that ideas are appropriately sorted, preventing misclassification.

2. Look beyond ease

While assessing process improvement ideas, don’t focus solely on ease of implementation. Consider their potential return as well. Sometimes, the simplest solutions yield the most significant benefits.

3. Visualize effort vs. impact

Lastly, create a visual comparison of action items. Evaluate them in terms of effort versus impact. This balanced approach ensures that you’re not chasing low-hanging fruit at the expense of substantial gains.

Misjudging the effort and impact of tasks

Implementing Lean Manufacturing techniques can inadvertently lead to underestimating the effort and impact of tasks. This oversight often occurs during the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase of the Six Sigma methodology. Beware—it could compromise your return on investment.

To mitigate this risk, consider leveraging Lean Six Sigma tools like the Impact Effort Matrix and Ease Impact Matrix. These tools provide a visual framework for categorizing action items based on ease/cost of implementation. By accurately assessing effort and impact, you’ll make informed decisions.

Overlooking the importance of team collaboration

In the world of Lean Manufacturing, overlooking team collaboration is a cardinal sin. Generating process improvement ideas requires collective effort. The Impact Effort Matrix can foster collaboration by visually comparing potential action items. Engage all team members during the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase to maximize your Six Sigma ROI.

Conclusion: maximizing the use of PICK Charts in your agency

In conclusion, PICK charts wield immense power within your agency’s Lean Manufacturing and Six Sigma strategies. They empower you to implement and categorize process improvement ideas effectively. Picture this: a visual comparison of potential returns against implementation costs. These charts shine brightest during the Identify and Prioritize Opportunities Phase, guiding your team toward impactful decisions. So, embrace PICK charts—they’re your secret weapon for success!

Try Bonsai - Best Project Management Software
Related Articles